Matt C. Abbott
Brown, Pavone and the 'Personhood' controversy
FacebookTwitterGoogle+
By Matt C. Abbott
November 4, 2011

From an Oct. 31 opinion piece in The New York Times, written by I. Glenn Cohen and Jonathan F. Will (click here to read the full commentary):

    'On Nov. 8, Mississippi voters will be asked to decide on a proposed amendment to the state constitution, which would define as a person 'every human being from the moment of fertilization, cloning, or the functional equivalent thereof.'

    'Most of the debate on this proposal has fallen on traditional lines. In our charged political climate, that is understandable, but it is also profoundly misleading. Whether one supports abortion rights or not, there are serious issues with this amendment — not because of the principles it seeks to represent, but because, as a legal matter, it is profoundly ambiguous....

    'Mississippi voters, whatever their views on abortion, deserve an amendment that is clear on its face. This is not such an amendment.'

I asked two pro-life leaders (via email), American Life League's Judie Brown and Priests for Life's Father Frank Pavone, to comment on the aforementioned opinion piece.

Mrs. Brown's response:

    'The purpose of a personhood amendment should be to recognize the human rights of all persons, born and preborn, from the beginning of their existence until death. The entire effort to focus on human rights has been more or less hijacked in Mississippi because the language of the amendment itself is unwieldy.

    'One of the reasons why American Life League insists on clear language such as 'biological beginning' or 'creation' is that definitions are key and today's embryology textbooks and experts have made it clear that the word 'fertilization' refers to a process. This means that many preborn babies who are asexually reproduced, for example, will not have the blessing of having their human rights protected by a proposal like the one being promoted in Mississippi.

    'Further, it is true that once an amendment is in place in a state constitution, the lawmakers of the state must address what sort of laws need to be in place to enforce the provision in the amendment, such as protection of human rights for all individual human beings.

    'What the personhood movement needs is consistency in language and an unassailable set of apologetics; sadly, both are lacking in Mississippi.'

Father Pavone's response:

    'A certain Scripture comes to mind about straining the gnat and swallowing the camel. We have a holocaust on our hands because an entire segment of humanity [preborn babies] are defined as non-persons. It's time to start reversing that mistake, however imperfect we think those efforts may be. The children whose arms are being torn off and whose heads are being crushed don't have time for ivory tower conundrums to get in the way of their protection.'



Pertinent links:

Personhood Mississippi

American Life League

Priests for Life

© Matt C. Abbott

 

The views expressed by RenewAmerica columnists are their own and do not necessarily reflect the position of RenewAmerica or its affiliates.
(See RenewAmerica's publishing standards.)

Click to enlarge

Matt C. Abbott

Matt C. Abbott is a Catholic commentator with a Bachelor of Arts degree in communication, media and theatre from Northeastern Illinois University. He also has an Associate in Applied Science degree in business management from Triton College. He's been interviewed on MSNBC, Bill Martinez Live, WOSU Radio in Ohio, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel's 'Unsolved' podcast, WLS-TV (ABC) in Chicago, WMTV (NBC) and WISC-TV (CBS) in Madison, Wis., and has been quoted in The New York Times and the Chicago Tribune. He can be reached at mattcabbott@gmail.com.

(Note: I welcome thoughtful feedback and story ideas. If you want our correspondence to remain confidential, please specify as such in your initial email to me. However, I reserve the right to forward and/or publish emails that are accusatory, insulting or threatening in nature, even if those emails are marked confidential. Also, if you give me permission to publish a quote of yours, please do not contact me at a later time to request that I delete your name. Only in limited circumstances will I quote anonymous sources. Thank you and God bless!)

Subscribe

Receive future articles by Matt C. Abbott: Click here

More by this author

October 28, 2018
A Catholic priest's unsolved murder and a Church in crisis


October 4, 2018
Accused Minnesota priest speaks out, pleads for justice


September 25, 2018
'Credibly accused' Catholic priest wins court case


September 22, 2018
Chicagoís Cardinal Cupich removes pastor who was sex abuse victim


September 17, 2018
Cardinal O'Malley and the Father Cuenin controversy


September 15, 2018
Slain priest's 'intimate relationships'?


September 9, 2018
Catholic watchdog group returns with revamped mission


September 6, 2018
Who can properly investigate the Catholic Church's sex abuse crisis?


August 30, 2018
Francis, Benedict, ViganÚ, Sipe, Abbott; Did Albany priests refer women for abortions at Planned Parenthood?; Cupich's recent remarks


August 11, 2018
'Agnes' and the Bernardin legacy


More articles