Sharon Hughes
February 16, 2004
Crooked and straight cops
By Sharon Hughes

A Policeman's job can be a thankless job, and police discouragement is not limited to any one city. As James D. Steffens, a police lieutenant in Clearwater, Fla., points out, "I've attended the autopsies of a newborn, a 1-month-old infant and a 7-month-old baby — all during a two-week period while going home each night to my own expectant wife. I've gone through countless doorways and searched untold darkened areas for felons who would do anything — including killing me and others — so as not to go back to prison. I've made countless death notifications and arrested way too many mothers and fathers in front of their children. And I know all too well what it's like to try to save a man from harming himself or others and then having him turn on me, doing his best to hurt me."

Maybe it's because my father was a policeman when we lived in Pennsylvania, or that one of my youngest son's best friends is a dedicated cop, but I have a tendency to think that the majority of police officers are straight cops. Like our firemen and military, policemen take on these jobs for noble reasons. If all you want is a paycheck there are plenty of other professions besides these that may require the laying down of your life. These tough jobs still represent true American heroes to young and old alike. What little boy has not wanted to be a fireman when he grows up?

Are cops perfect? No. Some of them go too far? Yes. Is that okay? Of course not. Sure there are some crooked cops...and how despicable they are, not worthy to be counted in the company of the honest ones. But one rotten apple doesn't mean the whole basket has gone bad.

However, there are those who would have us believe that the majority of cops are crooked, untrustworthy, unable to control themselves, and racist. It is not hard to find anti-cop sites on the internet, mostly run by anarchist groups that declare we live in a police state. While these are extreme accusations, it is true that one crooked or out of control cop can taint the reputation of the force in the minds of the public, especially if he is not brought to justice.

However, of real concern are the restraints put on police officers today, such as not being able to arrest illegal immigrants in San Francisco because of fear of racial profiling. The OCC, a police watchdog group working with the ACLU, has helped generate an attitude that police are guilty until proven innnocent. Peace protests often cry "police brutality!" when efforts are made in crowd control. Cross-dressers cry "insensitive!" when police fail to address them by the proper pro-noun of who they are for that day.

We can consensus-build and sensitivity-train our police right out of the protection we need and the purpose for which we have law enforcement in the first enforce the law and catch the criminals so that law-abiding citizens are safe. There are two ways to skin a cat...if you can't prevent a certain law you can tie the hands of the enforcers of that law. Laws without effective law-enforcers are impotent in the face of the lawless. We need the police and we need them to be free do their job...just as we need our military to be free to capture our enemies.

I have found that the policemen I've met are humble guys. A couple of years ago when an organization I belonged to decided to honor our firemen and policemen because of 911, just like our military, when they were acknowledged their response was a display of humility...and you sensed it is duty that counts to them, not recognition...they're just doing their job.

In researching for two recent shows on police issues I ran across the following entitled The Perfect Cop, author unknown, that I think you'll appreciate...

"To a Police Chief, the perfect cop is someone who looks sharp, works hard and doesn't expect overtime pay, makes good arrests without offending anyone, writes detailed reports and keeps a neat, readable activity log. He is also always available when extra help is needed, accepts work assignments willingly and comes up with fast, favorable results. In short, a perfect cop is someone who makes the Chief look good.

To a Prosecuting Attorney, a perfect cop is a meticulous investigator who gathers and documents evidence, obtains confessions to all crimes and outlines each case in order to make the prosecutor's job easy. He doesn't object when a case is plea bargained so the attorneys can go golfing on Friday afternoon, and doesn't mind if an offender gets probation or a suspended sentence because it is more convenient to make a deal than go to trial.

To a Defense Attorney, a perfect cop is a bungling idiot who makes mistakes and someone the defense attorney can manipulate and make angry in court, making the attorney look good in front of his client. A perfect cop is someone who will agree to any and all plea bargaining proposed, and whom the defense attorney can call when he needs protection from his own client.

To the City Council, a perfect cop is someone who does his job well without making waves, who is grateful for a job that he willingly works nights, weekends and holidays. He never asks for more than the city is willing to pay, does an exemplary job without adequate equipment and tools. Best of all, he never writes tickets on any council member or their kid.

To the People of the Community, a perfect cop is polite, a friendly person who walks the beat and checks out strange noises and watches for strange people. He teaches kids right from wrong, talks to them about the evils of drug use-but doesn't mention Mom and Dad using alcohol. He will arrest drug dealers, but overlooks kids with a "little" pot.

To his Wife, a perfect cop never lets his job effect his emotions. He can spend hours dealing with drunks, domestics, drug users, injured or dead people, and then come home and be a loving, well-adjusted husband and father.

I have been a cop for over 20 years, and have never met a perfect cop. Only a few have even come close, being totally honest and truly caring about people and doing the best job they can.

But all the cops I have ever known are human. They love, laugh, cry, hurt, and sometimes die too young. They try to make it to retirement, although many do not. Divorce is common. Some become alcoholics and some suffer from "police stress," seen in a variety of emotional disorders or heart attacks. Our job is often described as 98% boredom and 2% sheer terror.

Why do we do it? We don't really know. I hope it's because we simply care about right and wrong."

Prompted thought from my interviews with Officers Robert DeGeorge and Michael Nevin, which you can hear online at

© Sharon Hughes


The views expressed by RenewAmerica columnists are their own and do not necessarily reflect the position of RenewAmerica or its affiliates.
(See RenewAmerica's publishing standards.)

Click to enlarge

Sharon Hughes

Sharon Hughes is Founder and President of The Center for Changing Worldviews and the host of Changing Worldviews & WOMANTalk radio on KDIA in San Francisco, NPLR and online at Salem Web Network’s Her articles appear in many recognized news sites and publications, including FRONTPAGEMAG. She also blogs for, a division of The Media Research Center, and has appeared on FOX News and other national radio programs.


Receive future articles by Sharon Hughes: Click here

Latest articles