James Lambert
Once again, 9th District court overturns popular vote, San Diegans outraged
By James Lambert
January 20, 2011

Last Saturday, hundreds of San Diegans met at Mt. Soledad Memorial Park to protest a recent decision by the U.S. 9th District Court of Appeals. The court's ruling stated that the 57 year old cross which is on government owned grounds and is part of a war memorial, is "unconstitutional."

This most recent ruling is yet another episode in the 21 year old legal battle. The original law suit was brought in 1989 "when Phillip Paulsen, an atheist filed suit, and a court ordered the city to remove the cross. San Diego responded by placing the property for sale, with the approval of 76% of voters. But the subsequent sale was ruled unconstitutional after Paulsen objected, arguing the sale had the effect of preserving the cross" (Lambert, WND). Interestingly I once asked Mr. Paulsen to debate the issue on my local TV show, Night Lights (www.JamesLLambert.com) ... But after talking to Paulsen on the phone, I sensed that it might be challenging to conduct a debate free from coarse language.

In 2006, the Mt. Soledad Memorial (and Cross) was transferred to the federal government thanks to Congressional action (HR 5683) that was heavily supported by Cong. Duncan Hunter (R-El Cajon), Brian Bilbray (R-SD), Senator Jeff Sessions (R-Alabama) and then President George W. Bush. The bill had strong behind the scenes backing by AFA founder, Donald Wildmon and former Liberty University President Jerry Falwell, whom I interviewed about the case in 2005.

Nevertheless, the legal battle continued. This time it was with another plaintiff since Paulsen died in October 25, 2006. An appeal defying the transfer was made by the ACLU to the 9th District Court of Appeals (in 2009) which several weeks ago made the decision that the cross was "unconstitutional."

It is estimated that Saturdays gathering was attended by around 400-500 people. Many of those attending the gathering expressed concern about the recent demonstration of the court's unbridled power to overturn the vote of the people. The 9th Dist. court, based in San Francisco, has overturned the will of the people in two prominent cases in California in the last 18 months.

On two occasions San Diegans have overwhelmingly (70+ %) voted to retain the cross as a war memorial. In 2000, (Prop. 22) and in 2008, (Prop. 8) a majority of Californians (63% and 53% respectively) voted to uphold traditional marriage.

Now both issues have been overturned by an out of touch District Court. As it now stands, the 9th District judiciary is considered by some as the most liberal court in America. It appears that this case, like the one involving traditional / gay marriage, will eventually be heading to the Supreme Court.

All told, this is yet another reason why the current occupant of the White House, the most liberal President in American history, must be defeated in 2012!

Photos taken by James Lambert

© James Lambert


The views expressed by RenewAmerica columnists are their own and do not necessarily reflect the position of RenewAmerica or its affiliates.
(See RenewAmerica's publishing standards.)

Click to enlarge

James Lambert

James Lambert has a broad business background. After receiving his undergraduate degree from Linfield College (McMinnville, Oregon), Lambert pursued a career in banking by working in various management capacities for Crocker Bank, San Diego Trust & Savings Bank and First Interstate Bank (between 1973 and 1995). By 1990 Lambert received his Master in Business Administration from National University (San Diego). For 3 years, Lambert also taught Finance at Mira Costa Community College... (more)


Receive future articles by James Lambert: Click here

More by this author

June 24, 2019
Remembering a former roommate and recalling his wonderful story

May 16, 2019
Dem's 'Green Initiative', if enacted, will create financial chaos across the country

May 15, 2019
Constant IPhone use a major distraction within families and with many parents & their kids

January 31, 2019
For the good of the country: Dems need to negotiate & compromise with the President

December 21, 2018
2018 Tijuana murder rate 3x's higher than Chicago: Build border wall now!

November 30, 2018
CA park visitors noticed 'Do not report fires' signs while witnessing a non-monitored roadside fire

October 19, 2018
Democrats, MeToo movement: Hypocritical on the sexual assault issue

August 15, 2018
CA Democrats continue to ignore need for new water sources like desalinization plants

June 11, 2018
High crime rate in Mexico warrants building a wall

March 3, 2018
Gospel artist Edwin Hawkins & his music will be missed

More articles